junya ishigami wins golden lion for best project at the venice biennale
japanese firm junya.ishigami+associates has been awarded the golden lion for best project at the 12th international architecture biennale in venice, italy. ‘architecture as air: study for château la coste’ explores a new form of transparency that goes beyond the density and opacity of a building’s structural components. by blurring the limiting boundaries between space and structure, the project essentially aims to illustrate architecture as air, which transcends the concepts of lightness and weight. measuring approximately 14m in depth, 4m across and 4m high, the installation is a physical model of a building planned for somewhere in europe. by building it at full-scale, it should enable the viewers to perceive the otherwise invisible void, an element that is, much like air, smaller than anything of an everyday scale.
collapsed structure
image © designboom
constructed out of spindly carbon fiber pillars, the installation first collapses hours after the opening of the press preview on august 26, 2018. through numerous trials and errors, ishigami’s team worked on rebuilding the structure while simultaneouslyrefining the original idea, resulting in just the pillars for the final presentation. nevertheless, the international jury appreciated ishigami’s ‘unique and uncompromising vision, which pushes the limits of materiality, visibility, tectonics, thinness, and ultimately of architecture itself.’
damaged exhibition
image © designboom
problems continued on the second day
image © designboom
during the first three days, small groups of workers were trying to figure out how to reconnect the piece.
in the foreground, the semi-circle cardboard templates were used to glue the carbon fibers into shape
image © designboom
installation view before the opening of the exhibition
image courtesy contessanally
the château la coste winery is the site of a new arts center in the south of france, commissioned by irish property developer paddy mckillen and masterplanned by japanese architect tadao ando. currently under construction, the project is located in aix-en-provence and includes structures designed by leading architects, among them jean nouvel, frank gehry, norman foster and renzo piano.
update:
our friends at ARTit have just published a nice interview with junya ishigami.they met with ishigami at his office in tokyo while he was preparing for v enice, and discussed with him the role of exhibitions in his experimental practice and the idea of architecture after ideology.
junya ishigami (22 articles)
junya ishigami to design 2019 serpentine pavilion in london
junya ishigami creates 12-meter cantilevered display shelves for JINS eyewear store
junya ishigami's art biotop project of a water garden in tochigi, japan opens
junya ishigami's 'freeing architecture' exhibition opens at fondation cartier
junya ishigami shows ‘freeing architecture’ at fondation cartier in paris
renzo piano, emre arolat + elemental among finalists for doha art mill project
venice architecture biennale 2010 (69 articles)
OMA to restore 16th century venetian palazzo into department store
kazuyo sejima: venice architecture biennale 2010 closing ceremony
mark pimlott and tony fretton: piazzasalone
architecture news
MIT researchers discover way to move 25 ton stones with only their hands
#architecture
cambridge-based firm matter design unveils research on seemingly 'weightless' concrete forms.
cambridge-based firm matter design unveils research on seemingly 'weightless' concrete forms.
NUDES uses straw bales to create a breathable skin for proposed school in malawi
#architecture
the scheme uses local materials and embraces vernacular architecture to propose a building that fits within the east-african context.
the scheme uses local materials and embraces vernacular architecture to propose a building that fits within the east-african context.
'what if' by m²ft architects superimposes iconic architecture onto the city of rome
#architecture
the project shows famous architecture from around the world relocated in rome, such as the london eye dropped into the roman forum.
the project shows famous architecture from around the world relocated in rome, such as the london eye dropped into the roman forum.
3GATTI envisions the 'green spaceship' library landing in madrid's villaverde
#architecture
the concept aims to create a new landmark - a public building that is not hidden from citizens, but attracts them inside.
the concept aims to create a new landmark - a public building that is not hidden from citizens, but attracts them inside.
I don’t get it.
What am I looking at?
I’m sure part of the illegibility is due to the collapse of the project. If it remained standing like it was intended to in its original design, I imagine it would have been a stunning piece.
Even if we assume it was indeed a stunning piece, shouldn’t the fact that it collapsed before even the exhibition officially opened concern the committee that awarded the golden lion to this project? Overlooking the fact that most of them are critics and detached from practice (or rather, precisely for this reason) they should be able to discern between poetics of artistic laxity or plain dull mediocrity in cases of “conceptual” constructions like these. Most of the work this young architect has produced up to now is quite nice actually but should he get some sort of prestigious award I am not quite sure it makes sense it get it for this particular project. Just saying…
it’s so sad to see that award goes to the failed experimentation, not the successful execution of the solid idea. the explanation of the project sounds like architectural bs in academia, and if this is the representation of how architecture can blur and transcend itself beyond established boundary, the future of architectural discipline and theory is very doubtful.
Interesting, space as delineated concept. It’s more art than architecture, though. May I refer you to a couple of (unintentional?) antecedents: the Minimalist artist and sculptor Fred Sandback (deceased) and the contemporary Italian architect Dario Bartolini.
Footnote the artist Richard Tuttles’ string drawings from 15 years ago. This is a lame ripoff and only shows the weakness of the overall work…nothing new to see here !!! Move along!
Overheard at the Jury: The Emperor’s new building is truly beautiful! Do you not see it? Do you not believe it should receive the highest award??
bull s……..
!!! the emperor is naked !!!
I don’t think Ishigami was consciously copying any western precedents. But for people not living and working in Japan it might come as a surprise that copying is not entirely unacceptable in architecture (or art). The point here is that no matter how brilliant the idea (which perhaps was not all that brilliant or original in the first place) it is quite obvious that it failed to present itself successfully. Or perhaps people did indeed meet in architecture as some careless visitor may have knocked it down…
Anyway, at least he went through the trouble of doing something new for the exhibition. Fujimoto sent another iteration of his Primitive Future House and Ito a 10-year old project…Disappointing
@Airchitecture: great comment, very fitting!
I think the most interesting part about the project is the multiple iterations that it went through during the several days it was being fixed and rebuilt. The original idea, I admit, is kind of easy and unoriginal, but I’m sure the jury appreciated some of the lateral thinking that went into the post-build phase.
Fail! goes to show it’s not what you do – it’s who you know!
“The Emperor’s New Clothes”
This is how nepotistic Japanese share their power to the next generation. Classic!
You’d think they could’ve tested (or at least calculated) the strength of those carbon fibre columns BEFORE the biennale.
FAIL
I agree w/ @Ichi and @Pier. Sejima’s curation of the Biennale seems nepotistic and unoriginal.
Ishigami’s current exhibition in Tokyo also exposes his career to be little more than naive oversimplification inflated by media favoritism. It’s painful to see this inexperienced architect placed on an international platform and fail in such a publicly humiliating way.
What a cruel jury to award him the prize.
I think the finished image pre-collapse is very beautiful. Even the failures look nice — I look forward to seeing more Ishigami buildings in the future.
Agreed. The pre-collapse image is really stunning. It’s a shame that the final product is not much to look at (literally) but I appreciate his persistence and working methods.
this jury gave away so many awards(6), it seems they decided to give one each and then had a draw to see who would give which. obviously this one is what sejima got in the lottery.
it was torn down by a cat who sneaked in the building during the night. apparently it happened twice.. 🙂
Reminds me of Icarus- a bit to close to the sun.
I think the fact that it failed makes the exhibit more thought provoking.
But on some level it sets a bad precedent.
Can an injury be excused if the building is beautiful or conceptually interesting yet not well constructed?
The building collapsed nobody injured. It failed but it was good try so that I also give you the highest point.
Well done!…Is this an architectural joke?
no, no there was no cat, this was the journalist fairy tale everybody told. people like myths.
it just broke, it was unstable.
i gues, the photos dont show. should look different in life..?
I find that at least in photos it is much more compelling in its so-called ‘broken’ state. It actually reads like a kind of scratched photo – a kind of ethereal George Rousse experiment.
i did not get the concept